The Art of Keeping Secrets

A Veil Sundered Process Writing Life

The Art of Keeping Secrets

There's a particular temptation that comes with building a fictional universe: explaining the bloody thing.

You've worked out who knows what, why certain people behave the way they do, and which apparently insignificant decisions are going to become spectacularly important later. You've spent all that time making the pieces fit, and now there's a perfectly understandable urge to show everybody how clever the arrangement is.

Unfortunately, that tends to ruin the arrangement.

Because a secret in a story isn't simply information the author hasn't shared yet. At least, it shouldn't be. A good secret changes what people say, what they avoid saying, what they notice, and what they're prepared to do to keep somebody else from finding out.

And that makes it considerably more interesting than a surprise waiting at the end of a chapter.

A Secret Has to Do Something

It's easy enough to invent a mystery. Put something strange in a room, have everyone refuse to discuss it, and make ominous references to an event nobody will explain.

There. Mystery accomplished.

Except that isn't necessarily storytelling. Sometimes it's just a room full of people behaving like irritating bastards for the convenience of the plot.

If a character is keeping something important to themselves, I want to understand why. Are they protecting someone? Protecting themselves? Ashamed of what they did? Afraid of what another person might do with the truth?

Those motives matter because they turn silence into a decision.

And decisions have consequences, particularly when the person making them is convinced they're doing the right thing.

Three People, Three Different Stories

One of the more useful questions I can ask while writing a scene is quite simple: what does each person in this conversation believe is happening?

Not what is actually happening. Not what I know is happening. What they believe.

Imagine three people discussing an apparently ordinary problem. One knows the cause but can't admit it. Another suspects something is wrong but has drawn entirely the wrong conclusion. The third has no idea there's a secret at all and is wondering why everybody is being so bloody difficult.

They're having the same conversation, but they're not participating in the same story.

That's where the interesting behaviour begins. An innocent question sounds like an accusation. A perfectly reasonable answer feels evasive. Someone becomes angry, not because of what's been said, but because of what they think the other person knows.

Nobody needs to deliver a mysterious speech or stare meaningfully into the distance. They only need to behave according to the information they possess.

Which, naturally, is where keeping track of all that information becomes a problem for the author.

Mystery Isn't the Same as Confusion

There's a line between giving readers something to wonder about and leaving them with no bloody idea why anything matters.

I don't think a reader needs every answer immediately. I do think they need enough to understand the stakes of the scene they're reading.

If somebody refuses to open a door, I don't necessarily have to explain what's behind it. But I ought to give the reader a reason to care whether it gets opened.

Perhaps the person guarding it is frightened. Perhaps they're lying. Perhaps opening it would cost them something they're unwilling to lose.

Now the unanswered question has weight.

Without that, I'm not creating suspense. I'm asking the reader to wait patiently while I withhold the part that makes the scene interesting.

And patience, I've noticed, is not an unlimited resource.

The Trouble with Telling the Truth

Secrets also have an inconvenient tendency to become harder to manage the longer they're kept.

A lie told to avoid one difficult conversation can become the foundation of half a dozen others. Someone makes a choice based on incomplete information. Another person mistakes that choice for betrayal. By the time the truth finally comes out, the original problem might be the least important thing about it.

That's the sort of consequence I find worth exploring.

In A Veil Sundered, people don't all have access to the same knowledge, and they certainly don't agree on what should be done with it. But the interesting part isn't simply that some people know more than others. It's what they decide they're entitled to keep from the people affected by their decisions.

Sometimes silence is an act of care. Sometimes it's cowardice. Sometimes it's control dressed up in a very respectable coat.

And sometimes the person keeping the secret genuinely can't tell the difference.

Eventually, Somebody Has to Find Out

Of course, a secret can't remain interesting forever simply because I refuse to reveal it.

At some point, the truth needs to change something.

Maybe it explains a decision that previously seemed unforgivable. Maybe it destroys a relationship that was already balancing on a rather flimsy collection of assumptions. Maybe it turns out that the person who thought they understood everything was wrong about the one thing that mattered.

Whatever happens, the revelation has to earn the time spent waiting for it.

That's the test I keep coming back to. Not whether I can surprise a reader, but whether the truth makes the story they've already read mean something different.

Ideally, they'll look back and realise the clues were there all along.

And if they decide to reread a chapter because a perfectly ordinary conversation suddenly looks rather less ordinary?

Well, that's a lovely result.

Even if the poor bastard writing it had to remember what everybody knew, when they knew it, and precisely how much trouble that knowledge was going to cause.